Most writers are familiar with first
and third points of view and their variations.
But have you ever experimented with alternative
points of view? Below are some less used
points of view, what I call "unusual points
of view." Try using these when you're
blocked or you want to try something new.
Second Person Point of View
Second person can be written as "you"
singular or plural. Josip Novakovich in
FICTION WRITER'S WORKSHOP says: "The author
makes believe he's talking to someone,
describing what the person addressed is
doing. But the 'you' is not the reader,
though sometimes it's hard to get rid
of the impression the author is addressing
you directly."
Here's an excerpt from Italo Calvino's
first chapter of If on a winter night
a traveler. I think it's one of the most
engaging examples of second person point
of view. But if the author is not speaking
to the reader.then to whom? You be the
judge.
You are about to begin reading Italo
Calvino's new novel, If on a winter's
night a traveler. Relax. Concentrate.
Dispel ever other thought. Let the world
around you fade. Best to close the door;
the TV is always on in the next room.
Tell others right away, "No, I don't want
to watch TV!" Raise your voice-they won't
hear you otherwise-"I'm reading! I don't
want to be disturbed!" . . . So here you
are now, ready to attack the first lines
of the first page. You prepare to recognize
the unmistakable tone of the author .
. .
Most stories told in second person are
written in the present tense, so the reader
identifies directly with the character.
You're along for the journey, being an
active part of the story. I read this
excerpt feeling as if the author sees
me and is talking directly to me.
Like other points of view, second person
has its pitfalls. One of them is keeping
the reader's attention through the whole
story (in this example, an entire novel).
Some readers don't like to be told what
they're thinking and doing and saying.
Sometimes this point of view has a tendency
to sound too journalistic or like a recipe.
First Person Collective Observer Point
of View (or third person plural)
In this point of view the reader follows
the motions and acts of one person through
a group's viewpoint. Usually, someone
in the group acts as narrator but doesn't
have his/her own identity. Usually this
is reserved for small town narratives,
where an individual lives under communal
scrutiny. Schools, towns, churches, or
families focus on a secret person in conflict
with the community. In William Faulkner's
"A Rose for Emily" Emily is the character
scrutinized by the residents of Yoknapatawpha
County.
Here is an excerpt from the story which
occurs after she is put in the ground
and what "we" discover.
For a long while we just stood there,
looking at the profound and fleshless
grin. The body had apparently once lain
in the attitude of an embrace, but now
the long deep sleep that outlasts love,
that conquers even the grimace of love,
had cuckolded him . . . Then we noticed
that in the second pillow was an indentation
of a head. One of us lifted something
from it, leaning forward, that fast and
invisible dust dry and acrid in the nostrils,
we saw a long strand of iron-gray hair.
Third Person Plural Observer ("They")
Here the perceptions of a critical situation
comes from a group of characters who watch
the protagonist. It could be a group of
boys watching a teenage girl undressing
in her window as in: "They saw her in
the window." The excerpt from "A Rose
for Emily" might as easily be written
in the point of view.
First and Second Combined
This point of view is usually used in
love poetry, and rarely in fiction. In
this example from "The Roaring Bull and
Electra," a short story, it's an adult
daughter speaking to her father too ill
to speak for himself.
Today the new Roaring Bull was christened,
and I wanted you to be next to me as you
had been, twenty years ago . . . Now you
can't speak. You can barely swallow. I
used to feed you melted ice cream and
stroke your throat to get it down because
I thought the taste would remind you of
our ferry rides . . .
First and Third Combined
This point of view is used for characters
with a personality dichotomy, to look
at the same character from different angles.
In "Sarah Cole: A Type of Love Story"
Russell Banks does this to portray a narcissistic
man's affair with a homely woman.
I felt warmed by her presence and was
flirtatious and bold, a little pushy even.
Picture this. The man, tanned, limber
. . . enters the apartment behind the
woman.
The switch to third person is the character
taking a look at himself, the way one
might want to see himself projected onscreen.
The shift in point of view might be annoying
to the reader, so it's important to establish
this shift pattern early in your story.
Try this exercise:
Choose one of your favorite stories and
rewrite a scene from it in one of the
"unusual points of view." You might want
to try rewriting one of the excerpts above.
In your exercise show the original passage,
then your changed point of view (or points
of view). You get extra brownie points
if you write a scene from scratch. This
is a challenging exercise, but it also
shows you don't have to be limited by
variations of first and third person.
Let go, breathe deep, and have fun with
it!
2004 Rita Marie Keller
| About The Author
Rita Marie Keller has written and
published numerous stories, articles,
and essays. Her first novel, Living
in the City, was released September
2002 by Booklocker.com,
Inc. She founded the Cacoethes Scribendi
Creative Writing Workshop (www.cacoethes-scribendi.com)
in 1999.
|
This article was posted on April 12,
2004